Always good times when you use “The Mo”! I'm a fan of local garage sales and ever since wily neighbors starting accepting The Mo my spending has gone significantly up at them. You can always say oh I didn't bring enough cash, but you can always transfer more money into The Mo.
That cute old cabinet that will spend a long time in the garage before you sand and refinish it and paint it and decorate it and find a spot for it will be thrown in the back of the SUV .
I did the SAME THING! I sent a contractor (who is also a friend) $1500 I owed for remodeling. Or, so I thought. His name was rather unique. Or, so I thought. I was lucky. The name-alike agreed to send my money back to me. I had no recourse whatsoever if he'd refused. Lesson learned.
1) have the recipient “request a payment”. This method eliminates the mis-typing or mis-identification error.
2) have the recipient send their Venmo QR code- it’s unique to that recipient. (This method is pretty good, but doesn’t eliminate the potential error of typing in the wrong amount to the recipient).
Either method avoids the mistake you made when sending a stranger money.
PayPal has greater security too. For example if somebody Venmo’s me money and they do not make their payees private, you get to see all of the sender’s transactions.
I have not used any of these online money transactions due to the fear of the “Oops” factors. You just explained that there are some safety guard rails built in.
Well done, David. And a beautifully written post as well.
PS - about 100 pages into your new book and loving every minute of it! At 65, I am able to relive my own Apple memories starting with the Apple II - thanks!
I only trust Apple with cash transfers. Sure, it’s limited to those in Appleworld, but at least it’s secure and unlikely to have the weakness you experienced.
Just finished your book. My life in review for an Apple fan practically from day one. Thank you!
When I Venmo or Zelle someone for the first time, I always send only 5 or 10 bucks to test if it’s the intended recipient. Also, my issue with Venmo is the interest charged like credit cards do but not explicitly (why so many vendors ask for cash or a check and charge for credit card use.) When I had a fee long ago on my Visa I didn’t recognize and it was substantial, I found out it was a charge for a big sum I sent as a gift to my son. You do get airline points, and don’t with Zelle but no extra charge via Zelle.
It's truly Venmo's UX weak link. They've done probably the best they could with it, but I don't see how they can ever reduce the risk to zero. You're quite fortunate that you sent $1500 to an honest person! Or at least someone with a well-trained "scam alert" synapse in their brain.
Venmo is just PayPal. I tend to use PayPal because it is based on email addresses and has higher limits on cash transfers. For friend-to-friend transfers, there is no fee.
Great lesson ! I always send the recipient $1 first to make sure their email or phone and bank account are all working, and for them to verify that, AND then I send them the big bucks. Of course that does not help if the wrong recipient is entered the second time.
Apparently there's some sort of scam involved with sending money to a stranger and seeking a refund. Something to do with the scammer using a stolen card and keeping the voluntary refund even if the original credit card transaction is voided. Blocking seems prudent.
I have to share my Venmo mistake experience (not as good as yours).
I sent a payment for a tip to a guide (a few hundred dollars). I used his phone number (I had used him in the past).
But his phone number had changed since last time.
So, the $ went to a different guy who did not respond to my texts asking him to return funds.
I contracted Venmo. They initially refused to help, saying that since the stranger was in my contacts, I must know him (that’s a creepy thing about Venmo - when you consent to use them, you allow access to the contacts on your phone (and maybe other stuff)).
Anyway, I battled with them for a few days and eventually prevailed and got a refund, but it was not a pleasant experience!
Always good times when you use “The Mo”! I'm a fan of local garage sales and ever since wily neighbors starting accepting The Mo my spending has gone significantly up at them. You can always say oh I didn't bring enough cash, but you can always transfer more money into The Mo.
That cute old cabinet that will spend a long time in the garage before you sand and refinish it and paint it and decorate it and find a spot for it will be thrown in the back of the SUV .
I did the SAME THING! I sent a contractor (who is also a friend) $1500 I owed for remodeling. Or, so I thought. His name was rather unique. Or, so I thought. I was lucky. The name-alike agreed to send my money back to me. I had no recourse whatsoever if he'd refused. Lesson learned.
That is WILD… we are brothers in experience!
David—This was hilarious and sad all wrapped in one! She didn’t know who she was dealing with—kind of sad for her
2 suggestions for using Venmo.
1) have the recipient “request a payment”. This method eliminates the mis-typing or mis-identification error.
2) have the recipient send their Venmo QR code- it’s unique to that recipient. (This method is pretty good, but doesn’t eliminate the potential error of typing in the wrong amount to the recipient).
Either method avoids the mistake you made when sending a stranger money.
PayPal has greater security too. For example if somebody Venmo’s me money and they do not make their payees private, you get to see all of the sender’s transactions.
Thank you David.
I have not used any of these online money transactions due to the fear of the “Oops” factors. You just explained that there are some safety guard rails built in.
Cheers,
Kkb
Well done, David. And a beautifully written post as well.
PS - about 100 pages into your new book and loving every minute of it! At 65, I am able to relive my own Apple memories starting with the Apple II - thanks!
i’m so honored, John! Wait till you get to the next 500 pages! :)
I only trust Apple with cash transfers. Sure, it’s limited to those in Appleworld, but at least it’s secure and unlikely to have the weakness you experienced.
Just finished your book. My life in review for an Apple fan practically from day one. Thank you!
When I Venmo or Zelle someone for the first time, I always send only 5 or 10 bucks to test if it’s the intended recipient. Also, my issue with Venmo is the interest charged like credit cards do but not explicitly (why so many vendors ask for cash or a check and charge for credit card use.) When I had a fee long ago on my Visa I didn’t recognize and it was substantial, I found out it was a charge for a big sum I sent as a gift to my son. You do get airline points, and don’t with Zelle but no extra charge via Zelle.
It's truly Venmo's UX weak link. They've done probably the best they could with it, but I don't see how they can ever reduce the risk to zero. You're quite fortunate that you sent $1500 to an honest person! Or at least someone with a well-trained "scam alert" synapse in their brain.
You got lucky? I vote to avoid Venmo. Maybe techno clause would recommend going down chimney & leaving cash in stocking instead.
Venmo is just PayPal. I tend to use PayPal because it is based on email addresses and has higher limits on cash transfers. For friend-to-friend transfers, there is no fee.
Great lesson ! I always send the recipient $1 first to make sure their email or phone and bank account are all working, and for them to verify that, AND then I send them the big bucks. Of course that does not help if the wrong recipient is entered the second time.
Oh, that’s absolutely brilliant.
Sure is!😇😇
Apparently there's some sort of scam involved with sending money to a stranger and seeking a refund. Something to do with the scammer using a stolen card and keeping the voluntary refund even if the original credit card transaction is voided. Blocking seems prudent.
I have to share my Venmo mistake experience (not as good as yours).
I sent a payment for a tip to a guide (a few hundred dollars). I used his phone number (I had used him in the past).
But his phone number had changed since last time.
So, the $ went to a different guy who did not respond to my texts asking him to return funds.
I contracted Venmo. They initially refused to help, saying that since the stranger was in my contacts, I must know him (that’s a creepy thing about Venmo - when you consent to use them, you allow access to the contacts on your phone (and maybe other stuff)).
Anyway, I battled with them for a few days and eventually prevailed and got a refund, but it was not a pleasant experience!
Glad you sent your $ to an honest person!
My Venmo gripe is that the decimal point is NOT automatically inserted. At a yard sale, I almost Venmo’d the seller $180.00 instead of $18.